Perfume Review: Ramon Monegal Pure Mariposa for Neiman Marcus

Spring is in the air, though clearly some parts of the world don’t seem to be so fortunate. Nonetheless, it seemed to be a good time to try out a few light, fresh fragrances that epitomize the upcoming season. One, in particular, caught my attention: Pure Mariposa, the new perfume created by the Spanish niche perfume house of Ramon Monegal for the American luxury department store, Neiman Marcus. Pure Mariposa is a bespoke perfume exclusive to the store and was released in February 2013.

One Neiman Marcus store with a floating butterfly decor. Source: Flickr.

One Neiman Marcus store with a floating butterfly decor. Source: Flickr.

Neiman Marcus' butterflies.

Neiman Marcus’ butterflies.

“Mariposa” means butterfly in Spanish and is not only a reference to Neiman Marcus’ happy, bright symbol of butterflies but the perfume’s point of inspiration.

In the press release for the perfume, Ramon Monegal said: The butterfly is an extraordinary creature that embodies many of the values that motivate me when I look for inspiration to fashion an olfactory tale in the form of a perfume.”  That “olfactory tale” seems to be one of flowery nectar in an airy, ozonic green forest:

Pure Mariposa will offer a floral-nectar accord with a festive tone in a dew-covered green forest, surrounded by a breeze of ozonic air, on a rich bottom accord of amber and musk.

Ramon Monegal Pure Mariposa

Neiman Marcus describes this as a “fruity, green-floral, woody scent” and lists the notes with great descriptive flair. Since it is their perfume, let’s go with their version, but note how Ramon Monegal or Neiman Marcus is trying to cover every possible base or category of perfumery imaginable:

Top Note

  • Fresh festive colorful: orange, grapefruit, bergamot.
  • Fruity vital, cheerful: yuzu, black currant, plum.
  • Ozonic pure, graceful: helional, melonal, calone, ultrazur. (molecules)

Middle Note

  • Green natural: oakmoss, grass accord, fig.
  • Floral rich, elegant: Osmanthus, jasmine, lily of the valley, rose wardia, tuberose.

Base Note

  • Woody powerful, harmonious: sandalwood, cashmeran (m), iris, anchouli (m). 
  • Silky sophisticated, majestic: peach, tonka bean, amber.

I assume the “(m)” abbreviation stands for “molecules” but the reference to “anchouli” made me blink, so I turned to Fragrantica. To my relief, it doesn’t seem to stand for some sort of anchovy oil. Instead, “anchouli” seems to be either a typo (like another on Neiman Marcus’ page) or a reference to some sort of synthetic “patchouli.”

I’m not a fan of synthetics — and particularly not of calone — so the listing of six different aromachemicals gave me great pause. I approached Pure Mariposa with some trepidation and first just gave the small decant a sniff. It was absolutely gorgeous in the bottle! Let me repeat that again: gorgeous! A beautiful scent with fresh, sweet, fruited and bright green notes. I could detect grapefruit that was yellow and sweet, not red and tart, along with fresh yuzu, juicy, sun-ripened yellow citrus, sweet (non-artificial) melon, sweetly green lily-of-the-valley, and fig. There was also that cheerful, happy note of freshly cut grass that is so evocative of the summer and sunshine. I was thrilled, and quite relieved.

Then, I put it on my skin. And it was a very different story…. A huge waft of synthetics and chemicals immediately hit my nose, followed quickly by incredibly dry, pungent, bitter oakmoss and equally bitter grass. There were also a panoply of sour notes from the citrus elements which contrasted strongly with the sweetness of the melonal aromachemical. The pungently dry aspects of mineralized oakmoss were side by side with sweet melon and sour citrus —  all on a base of synthetics and artificially peppered woods. Soapy lily-of-the-valley lurked in the corners, adding a different sort of green and white impression to the whole ghastly mélange.

I don’t know if my skin magnifies synthetic aromachemicals or if there is simply too damn many of them in Pure Mariposa, but the contrast between the beautiful brightness of the perfume in the bottle and its manifestation on my skin was a huge disappointment. That robust underpinning of aromachemicals remained long after the perfume’s opening changed to something much less bitter and dry, and much more melon-y sweet, metallic and airily green.

Ten minutes in, the perfume became simultaneously even more bitter but, also, more sweet. The very dusty, dry, grey mineralized feel of the oakmoss competed with the green lily-of-the-valley’s sweetness, the freshness of yellow citrus and the feel of a green honeydew melon mounted on aquatic underpinnings of calone. The calone is just brutally strong in this perfume and truly dominates everything at its heart, while the melonal runs over the top of everything like a bulldozer. Yet, at the same time, there are synthetically peppered woods with a definite metallic, somewhat alcohol-like undertone.

Two hours in, I’m surrounded by a cloud of calone and melonal: aquatic melon freshness is everywhere. Within the cloud projecting several feet from my arm, the bitterness of very dry oakmoss remains but it’s underneath and on the skin, not wafting around. Some vaguely amorphous, abstract floral notes dance around, joined by occasional, fleeting flickers of powder and soap. At the same time, there is that annoying metallic, alcohol note that pops up every now and then, like a ghost flitting about under the endless mushroom cloud of fresh melon. The metallic note is not continuously present, but it never completely leaves, either. My mind is utterly confused by the endless contrast of bitter and sweet, dry and fresh, sour and aquatic, flowers and alcohol.

And the perfume remained that way for hours and hours without any fundamental change. The sillage dropped after about four hours but, like many perfumes with aromachemicals, it has persistent longevity. On my perfume-consuming skin, it lasted about 9 hours until I simply couldn’t take it any more and desperately sought a change. Yes, I washed it off. There is only so much melon and metallic alcohol a person can take, after all!

On Fragrantica, there is only one review thus far for Pure Mariposa and it’s not an endorsement:

fresh but weird scent…drydown..is a cloying nutty smoky (think ur fireplace and throw orange peels in and let them dry out…took days to take off my skin…good last power..but the scent is kinda like beautiful(C KLEIN)..but with burnt notes…im not fond of.

I’m sad to say that I think their experience was still better than mine.

For the sake of fairness, I should point you to The Non-Blonde who received an early press sample and who had a very positive experience with the perfume, though she shared my initial trepidation when reading the large list of synthetics in the notes:

Ramon Monegal chose to also list several of the synthetic molecules: helional (a green hay-like grassy odor), melonal (excatly [sic] what it says), calone (usually the worst marine-ozonic offender), ultrazur (another fresh-ozonic beast, sweeter and greener than calone). It sounds like a warning sign and it took all my trust in Ramon Monegal’s perfumery skill and style to make me take that first spritz on my wrist.

I shouldn’t have worried. While Pure Mariposa opens with a burst of sharp and fresh citrus oil, I don’t smell the sea or any rotten melons; just air from a window opened early in the morning, letting in cool air. It’s a mix of bright yellow and bright green: the freshly mowed grass, a glass of freshly squeezed grapefruit juice, meyer lemons arranged in a bowl on the table. Then things become more floral as the day (and Pure Mariposa) starts to unfold. New blossoms open every day, white, pink, and orange. The heart is rather abstract, I can’t say “here’s muguet! there’s rose!”, but it is very floral, slightly honeyed (those fresh water molecules are gone and forgotten), juicy and a bit pulpy. I do smell quite a bit of peach and it goes hand in hand with a strong tuberose note. There’s a point that Mariposa becomes a blend of powder and tuberose, very feminine on my skin (dry and woody on the husband) and if you over spray it really takes over the room.

On her skin, Ramon Monegal lasted 16 hours. In my opinion, that is further testament to the synthetic nature of the perfume since we all know that synthetics can make a perfume last forever — even when you wish the perfume would die, and die now.

Clearly, something about my skin chemistry seems to turn aromachemicals into something pretty extreme. I was with two people who aren’t perfumistas, but who absolutely loved the scent of Pure Mariposa that pulsated in the air like a sound wave. They found it “fresh and sweet.” (Apparently, they love melonal more than I do.) Nonetheless, when one of them smelled it on my arm, they grimaced.

My reviews are based solely my personal (and, therefore, obviously subjective) experience with a scent. And, on my skin, there is something incredibly artificial, chemical, and unpleasant about Pure Mariposa. If you love very fresh, melon-y, floral, green, woody fragrances and if you can’t smell any metallic undertone to calone’s aquatic notes or aren’t sensitive to aromachemicals in general, then this may be one for you to try. But make sure you don’t just smell it in the bottle or on a strip of paper. This is one you need to actually apply to your skin! Also, beware the amount that you apply and perhaps reconsider wearing it to the office. As the Non-Blonde noted, this is a “robust” scent, so “be careful if you’re around grumpy office people who don’t appreciate this colorful scented presence.”

Personally, I wouldn’t recommend this with a ten-foot pole unless you know ahead of time that you like synthetics, especially melonal and calone. Not for $200 a bottle. Oh, did I not mention the cost? It’s $200 for a 1.7 ounce bottle of eau de parfum. I won’t bring up Neiman Marcus’ pejorative nickname, but I think those of you outside America should count yourselves fortunate that this exclusive item is not available for shipping overseas.

All in all, a huge disappointment. 

DETAILS:
Pure Mariposa is an Eau de Parfum that comes only in a 1.7 oz/50 ml bottle and costs $200. It is exclusive to Neiman Marcus. Unfortunately, the department store will not ship or export the perfume outside of the United States. I went to the page and tried numerous different countries in the “Shipping to” link at the top, and each time received a message in the lower right-hand corner stating, “We are sorry, but we are unable to ship this item to _______[insert country’s name].” As for samples, I don’t see the perfume listed yet on any of the US perfume decanting sites.

29 thoughts on “Perfume Review: Ramon Monegal Pure Mariposa for Neiman Marcus

  1. What a disappointment to have something so promising in the bottle be so disappointing in person! I’m not super keen on paying $200 for 50ml of something filled to the brim with synthetics, which I believe are usually quite inexpensive.

    • I tried so hard to restrain myself from bringing up Neiman Marcus’ nickname but it seems the most appropriate response to your comment: “Needless Mark-up”….. 🙂

      • Hee! Re: ISO E, my understanding is that some people aren’t able to smell it at all. I don’t know, I’ve only ever tried one thing that I know was loaded with it (Molecule 01 I believe) and I don’t know if I can smell it, in particular. It’s also apparently very, very inexpensive, so it’s annoying that places are filling their perfume with it then charging a big time premium.

        Needless Markup, indeed. I can’t think of the last time I’ve been inside a Neiman Marcus. I can’t afford anything there, really (but I’ve never been one to spend much on clothing anyhow).

  2. The description certainly sounds appealing, and those decorations are awfully pretty, but … eek. I’ll have to wait and see until I test, but the synthetic barrage you described certainly isn’t appealing! 🙂

    • Hi Natalie, thank you for stopping by! 🙂 It certainly was lovely in the bottle but, yes, quite a different experience on the skin. I’d love to hear your thoughts if you get the chance to try it out. 🙂

  3. Pass. Besides the dreaded note which I will not mention la-la-la-la-la-la-la, I may never successfully wash this off given that it lasted on YOU for 9 hours (!) and on another person for sixteen hours!

    • It lasted on me in pulsating, never-ending waves for 9 hours *only* because I then WASHED IT OFF! God knows how long it would have remained otherwise. The poor person on Fragrantica said it took DAYS to get off her skin! *shudder*

      You have no idea how much I thought of you *each and every time* I typed out the words “lily of the valley”….. ROFL!! I could almost *see* you wincing as you read that. *grin*

  4. I am sure it will eventually make it to the States but I will not be seeking it out (although I must say I do like the bottle). When I read yuzu, osmanthus and sandalwood my eyes lit up but then all of those synthetics made me shy away (and I made the mistake of thinking anchovy at first as well and then thought must be patchouli). I prefer higher concentrations of naturals to synthetics.Like you I do not enjoy the way many synthetics smell on my skin…maybe this is why I am less moved these days as (correct me if I am wrong) the shift in mainstream perfume is heading towards more synth and less e.o.s. Have you ever tried yuzu or osmanthus essential oils straight up? Glorious!! and combined with a bit of frankincense…outrageously good!

    • It’s already here, sweetie. It’s exclusive to Neiman Marcus in the States and was released in February. It simply won’t be making its way to other shores.

      I’m glad I’m not the only one who thought of anchovies at first. LOL. As for the issue of synthetics, I definitely agree that mainstream perfumery is filled with them. It’s one reason why I rarely review such perfumes. It’s a perfect way for the companies to keep their costs down while being able to make a profit through higher retail prices. Synthetics are also a big part of or contributor to the mainstream obsession with “fresh” and/or “clean” scents (not to mention aquatic fragrances). As for essential oils, I’m afraid I’ve tried hardly any. But your combination sounds lovely. 🙂

      • oh my goodness you must really think me a moron! ( I misread as it is NOT in the States when in actuallity the opposite is true!). However in my defense, did you notice what time I left the comment? 4am, when I probably should not be reading and commenting as I am still not quite awake (unfortunately with three kids and hubby in the house all fighting for the computer 4am is my only quiet time!).
        You really need to try some real essential oils, they are perfumes unto themselves and absolutely amazing!!! One of these days I will make you a blend when I get a bigger picture of what your taste is like. the downside to essential oil blends is they do not project and don’t have the longevity that synths do.

        • Actually, I just assumed that the coffee hadn’t kicked in yet and that your eyes played tricks on you. I’ve noticed the time you post. You’re up when my insomniac self is just getting ready to get a few hours sleep. LOL. I would never have brought up the mistake but for the fact that you seemed interested in a lot of the notes so I wanted you to know the perfume is available, if you want to give it a sniff. That said — since you’re someone who blends and enjoys the real stuff with the essential oils and who also loves the really good, old stuff — I *highly* doubt you’d enjoy this synthetic bomb.

  5. I’ve been enjoying all the other samples I got from Ramon Monegal standard line, few of them are really good perfumes. Since this one is NM exclusive I will probably not be able to try it so thanks for your review.
    Though it smelled artificial and chemical on you still I would like to give it a chance

    • My experience continues and continues with this fragrance, as it seemed to have transferred over to some of my clothes and my sheets. And it just WON’T go away! At all. I had just changed the linens on my bed when I tested this, but thanks to that incessant note of chemical melon, I have had to change everything again and wash the sheets and my cardigan just to get rid of it. Synthetics…… gah!

  6. I know, it’s a perversion… but everything you wrote sounds like something I mightl ike… Well, everything but the price 😉

    I have no problems with synthetics – as long as it’s a complex enough composition (I really dislikedboth the idea and thesmell of Pentaccords) and even the opposite: when I read “all-natural”, I’m almost 100% sure I won’t like it.

    But still I enjoyedyour review – sorry 🙂

  7. Oh man. What an unpleasant experience! Kudos to you for not running to scrub. Maybe it would have been better if anchouli stood for some kind of anchovy/patchouli molecule thing . . . No, wait, that is a really gross thought!

    I do have to say that the bottles are soooo snazzy!

    • Noooooooooooooooo, don’t bring in anchovies into this heinous mix! Noooooooooooooooo…..! As it was, I could smell wafts of this emanating from parts of the house where I had just happened to apply it (on my skin) for days afterwards. It was determined to haunt me and make my life miserable. The lasting power of those synthetics was really frightening.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s